Receive a free download on Management Education and the SDGs

Subscribe to our newsletter and receive access to a free download of Management Education and the SDGs: Transforming Education to Act Responsibly and Find Opportunities, a resource that outlines how PRME and the UN Global Compact can support management education's engagement with the SDGs.

Subscribe
curtainNewsletter.heading
Business as War - A Reflection on the Language of Business Leadership Success
05 May, 2022 New York, United States

Business as War - A Reflection on the Language of Business Leadership Success

“Are you playing to play or playing to win” (Stalk and Lachenauer, 2004)

Business as War. A reflection on the language of business leadership success.

A professor colleague said to me not so long ago: ‘the language of business is war’. He asked me if I had noted how laden business talk is with phrases from war. How we, in our professional lives, hear managers, business consultants, business media and business school professors talk about business as if it is warfare: ‘win the battle’, ‘fight back’, ‘attack the enemy’, ‘defend our position’, ‘the market is a battlefield’, employees are ‘footsoldiers’, ‘being defensive is a losing strategy’, and ‘be prepared to fight’ with ‘aggressive tactics’. Some even go as far as talking about ‘killing the enemy’ when they describe the preferred way of engaging with other businesses operating in the same industry. The prestigious Harvard Business School Press published a business book called Hardball: Are you playing to play or playing to win describing companies who are “ruthless”, “mean”, “willing to hurt their rivals” and “enjoy watching their competitors squirm” (Stalk and Lachenauer, 2004). Machiavelli’s five-hundred-year old book describing war-like principles for leadership in The Prince (1532) somehow still seems to inspire and govern as an underlying principle for much of management training in classrooms around the world where we educate the next generation of leaders on what successful business looks like. It is almost as if ‘winning the war’ is the recipe for a successful business leader.

While some will argue that ‘these are just words’ and ‘it is just a way of framing the market context of business’, we also know that the way we frame the world in words affects the way we perceive the world, make decisions, and engage with each other. And war is a horrible metaphor for business. It frames the company as an adversarial approach to business responsibilities in which almost everyone outside the company becomes an enemy.

There is a profound need to review the language in business schools and the vocabulary with which we describe the role and responsibilities of the firm, as well as what it means to be a successful business leader. It is unlikely that the challenges of climate change, increasing inequalities, human rights abuses, the COVID-19 pandemic, and a decade-long decline in the percentage of people living in world democracies will be addressed and bettered if the world’s leaders engage with each other as enemies who are to be ‘won over’. If war is the prevailing metaphor for business, it implies an urgency to direct all resources to attend to and win that war, leaving other issues, such as human rights, inequalities and climate change, seeming less important.

Science has shown us that the planet is, more than ever, in need of leaders who can generate and manage partnerships across and within sectors, industries and countries to solve the planet’s fundamentally transnational problems. This requires frameworks of collaboration, co-ownership, participation, co-construction, and engaging a collective purpose. This requires a new language in our business school textbooks and curricula as well as the vernacular of the world’s business leaders, consultants and business media. There is emerging research and literature developing new frameworks with new business vocabulary. There is also an increasing number of deans specifically stating in policies and strategy documents that their vision is to educate leadership students with collaborative and empathetic mindsets, and to make businesses’ purpose addressing societal challenges.

The next important step is to see this research and these policy and strategy documents reflected more comprehensively in the vocabulary and frameworks of the world’s leadership education programs.

As we know: “if you want to change business, you want to change how business is taught.”


Mette Morsing

Head of PRME, Principles for Responsible Management Education

UN Global Compact, New York

References

Machiavelli, N. (reprint 1981). “The Prince”. New York, N.Y. :Penguin Books (Machiavelli lived 1469-1527 and his book ‘The Prince’ was written in 1513 and is dated to have been first published in 1532, five years after Machiavelli’s death)

Stalk, G. and Lachenauer, R. (2004). “Are you playing to play or playing to win.” Massachusetts: Harvard Business School Press

See also

https://englishwithatwist.com/2015/09/22/business-is-war-10-idioms/

https://shift.newco.co/2016/11/15/business-is-not-war-lets-stop-talking-like-it-is/

Recent Articles

30 July, 2025 New York, United States

Youth Innovation Takes Center Stage at HLPF 2025 to Tackle Global Water Challenges

News Youth Innovation Takes Center Stage at HLPF 2025 to Tackle Global Water Challenges
At an official side event of the UN High-Level Political Forum on Sustainable Development (HLPF) 2025, organized by PRME Students, HESI Student Action Group, and UNESCO IESALC, student leaders, academics, and innovators gathered to address one of the most pressing global issues: water. Titled “Solving Real-World Water Challenges through Empowering Student Innovation”, the event showcased how youth-led action, institutional support, and cross-sector partnerships are transforming the future of water stewardship. The challenge: water insecurity an

Continue Reading
28 July, 2025 New York, United States

Signatory Spotlight: MBA in Sustainability at Bard College, United States

Signatory Spotlights Signatory Spotlight: MBA in Sustainability at Bard College, United States
The Bard MBA in Sustainability is one of the few graduate business programs worldwide that fully integrates a focus on mission-driven business and sustainability into a core graduate business curriculum. The program enrolls over 130 students and has earned top global recognition, including being named the #1 Green MBA in the U.S. by Princeton Review for four consecutive years (2021-2024), the #1 MBA nationwide for Non-Profit Management, and the #3 “Better World MBA” in 2024 by Corporate Knights. Bard’s MBA has created a one-of-a-kind, comprehen

Continue Reading
17 July, 2025 New York, United States

Bridging Theory and Practice: Dr. Dewa Wardak’s Path to Purposeful Business Education

Impact Stories Bridging Theory and Practice: Dr. Dewa Wardak’s Path to Purposeful Business Education
When the University of Sydney Business School needed to shift to online teaching during the COVID-19 pandemic, Dr. Dewa Wardak was brought in, not from a traditional business background, but as a learning sciences expert. With a master degree in Learning Sciences and Technology and a PhD in educational design, Dr. Wardak had long focused on how students learn and how to make learning more meaningful. That expertise became a vital bridge between pedagogical theory and practical classroom transformation. During the COVID-19 pandemic, Dr. Wardak t

Continue Reading